Could a Montana Coin Jar Hold a Million-Dollar Penny?

Imagine having a few hundred thousand—or even a few million dollars—sitting in your house right now without even knowing it. Sounds far-fetched, right? Like one of those late-night infomercials promising you are the treasure and for just $19.99 a month… blah, blah, blah. But here’s the thing—this isn’t that.

There are rare pennies out there that are worth serious money, and you might actually have one. The odds aren’t great—but they’re not zero either. So before you dive into your Spring cleaning here in Montana, take a moment to examine that change jar or the coins in your junk drawer. One of those "worthless" pennies could be hiding a fortune and you might want to take a closer look.

1943-D Lincoln Wheat Cent: Bronze/Copper

It’s considered the holy grail of pennies, and there's a fascinating twist—very few of these were actually made with bronze during that year because they were supposed to be steel. A small batch of them ended up being minted with leftover copper from 1942.

The value of a genuine 1943-D Lincoln Wheat Cent can be jaw-dropping. In average condition, according to USA Coin Book, it can go for around $472,330, but if you're lucky enough to find one in perfect shape, it could be worth between $950,424 and a whopping $2,414,612! Crazy, right?

1944-S Steel Lincoln Wheat Cent

Similar to the 1943-D Lincoln Wheat Cent, this penny is valuable for it's unique material. All the pennies from 1944 were supposed to transition from steel back to copper/bronze, but a handful did not make it.

The estimated value of this penny is about $428,636 if it's in average condition, but if it's in mint condition, it could be worth between $795,399 and $1,191,536!

These are just a few of the valuable pennies that are listed as being worth tons of money and you can check out a larger list with details HERE.

Get our free mobile app

The takeaway? Think twice before dumping your change into a Coinstar machine. You never know what hidden gems might be mixed in. Better yet, do what I do—stash your coins in a jar and go through them on a rainy day. Even if they’re not worth millions right now, some might be down the line. Either way, you could be sitting on a small fortune and not even know it.